In 1969 The Middleman had an archnemesis named The Candle. When the dastardly villain disappeared, the 1969 Middleman took a drastic step by cryogenically freezing himself with strict instructions to be reanimated if and when The Candle should ever return. Thirty-nine years later, The Middleman and Wendy stumble across a new case that seems eerily similar to The Candle's M.O. While researching how to handle the old foe's return, Ida drops the bomb on them about her instructions to unfreeze the 1969 Middleman. Driven by a 40-year vendetta and a 1960s mind-set, will the old Middleman be able to work with The Middleman and Wendy to catch The Candle, or will their differences get in the way of justice?
Meanwhile, worrying about her "perfect" relationship with Tyler and how her job may interfere with it, Wendy goes to 1969 Middleman for advice.
2008 episode